Help! > Specific Engine Help

Bump valve uniflow engine

<< < (2/6) > >>

astroud:
Hi MJM
Thank you for your detailed analysis and explanation, it certainly helps me understand what I need to think about.
You mentioned my large port sizes but I have not set these yet. Others have mentioned the exhaust should be a number of small ports around the circumference but I cannot see why, surely the same as one single large port.
The inlet timing can be changed by swapping out the plunger on the piston to a different length, the dead volume can be changed by altering the conrod length and I plan a 3 piece conrod to make this possible. However the exhaust timing is not so easy to alter, only by plugging and re drilling.
Time to start cutting some metal!

Andrew

Jasonb:
One large diameter hole is uncovered for a longer part of the stroke than a series of smaller ones though I have seen engines done both ways.

Charles Lamont:

--- Quote from: Jasonb on August 05, 2026, 10:02:03 am ---
--- Quote from: Charles Lamont on August 05, 2026, 09:40:10 am ---There is, however, another consideration. The exhaust is going to atmosphere. Assuming the exhaust port closes with the pressure at 1 bar. A 7:1 compression ratio would mean that the engine will not run with a supply pressure below 7 bar.   

--- End quote ---

The couple of uniflow engines I recently got running had very little head clearance so the compression ratio would have been quite high and probably more than 10:1 but they run on 2 to 3 bar with no problem.

You can see how little clearance and get an idea of piston movement from the crankshaft

https://www.modelenginemaker.com/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=12854.0;attach=184323;image

--- End quote ---

Hmm ... scratching head ATM. That illustration does show a huge flywheel. And the poppet valve timing is probably different to what you would get with a bash valve.

MJM460:
Hi Charles, thank you for some well thought out comments.  You are quite right that for any given compression ratio, there is a supply pressure below which the engine does not produce any work on the power stroke, so the engine will not run.

I must admit that it was not obvious to me, though I should have known, as Benson and Rayman mentioned it in their book on Experimental Flash Steam, which I bought back when it was first published many years ago, and have read it many times.  Their explanation was simply that it was “obvious”.  So back to the indicator diagram to work out what is going on.

Step one is to draw the compression curve for a higher compression ratio, one that gives a pressure above the supply pressure before the valve starts opening.  5B in the diagram below.

When the valve starts opening, the cylinder is no longer a closed space, so the curve changes as the gas, now at higher pressure than the supply,  can now flow into the supply system, and the operating point moves towards point 6 at top dead centre, and approximately constant pressure towards point 1 when the valve closes.

Now the issue finally is obvious, even to me.  The power stroke starts with lower pressure than the compression stroke pressure at the point where the valve is just closed!  At the higher compression ratio, the operating point would follow the dotted line as the piston moves down.  Clearly the power stroke does not produce as much work as absorbed by the compression stroke, so the engine cannot run.  In practice, the upper limit to compression ratio is a bit lower than necessary to just meet the supply pressure at  5, as there must be enough work produced to overcome friction and other inefficiencies in order to run.

We have already concluded that a higher compression ratio produces less output, we can add that the compression ratio must be lower than necessary to equal the supply pressure at the end of the stroke.

Benson and Rayman do mention another result from their experimentation, the power output does seem to be quite sensitive to compression ratio, and a significant 100% increase in power came from optimising the compression ratio on their setup, but that is another study.  I suspect the extra steam consumption at lower compression ratio was taxing their steam supply.

Andrew, I am glad you have found this helpful.   We can certainly conclude that designs that allow adjustment of the compression ratio are worthwhile.  As to the issue of exhaust hole sizes, assuming a similar total flow area, a larger hole requires more piston travel to completely cover and uncover, while multiple small holes can uncover the same flow area with less travel, leaving more travel for expansion (and compression)as Jason described.  The larger hole also gives more open time to let the pressure to get to atmospheric pressure before the hole is finally closed, a further advantage.  If you do the diagram assuming very small holes, then again with very large holes, you will see the difference.  You probably will see it best by exaggerating the difference in hole size, as the inaccuracy of the curve from points 2 to 4 in yesterday’s drawing may hide small differences.  In general, it is better to have the exhaust hole area too large than too small.  If you are interested in experimenting it may be worth making a cylinder with small holes and in addition, a larger hole that has provision to be blocked off with a screw.  You would be able then test the effect, but probably not worth doing unless you are a very keen experimenter.

Looking forward to seeing the engine progress,

MJM460

Jasonb:

--- Quote from: MJM460 on August 06, 2026, 03:08:49 am ---Hi Charles, thank you for some well thought out comments.  You are quite right that for any given compression ratio, there is a supply pressure below which the engine does not produce any work on the power stroke, so the engine will not run.

--- End quote ---

Surely the engine does work on the power stroke as the piston will move to BDC. However if you don't get enough energy into the flywheel then it will not return and pass TDC .

When the guy who owned those two engines first asked me about them I did say they would need a reasonable pressure and to try 50psi just over 3 bar and to give the flywheel a good spin. as you won't get them to start on a few psi like a slide valve engine but can wind down the wick once they are running.

You might want to look at the similar thread I did on ME about the restoration as there is a post which has copies of  the article on the "Don" engine it was said to be based on complete with indicator diagram and what pressures were showing.

The cams look to be lined up with the crankshaft throw so no lead which would be similar to the timing you would get with a bump valve

https://www.model-engineer.co.uk/forums/topic/me-vol-48-no-1136-of-1923/

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page

[*] Previous page

Go to full version